EVRAZ: Court rejects claim concerning late allocation of shares
The State Commercial Court of the Moscow Region has dismissed in full a claim brought by a shareholder of EVRAZ plc who allegedly failed to meet the publicly announced deadline of 24 November 2025 for the allocation of shares. The claimant is a Russian citizen. The judgment was issued on 2 October 2026.
The importance of proper notification
As previously discussed in our presentations, one of the potential grounds for challenging the outcome of the allocation procedure concerns whether investors were duly notified in accordance with Federal Law No. 470-FZ.
Under the law, the Russian company is required to notify known eligible holders using the available means of communication. In this context, a potential legal argument concerns whether publication of information on a Russian-language website alone was sufficient, particularly where individual notification was required.
For investors who remained unaware of the allocation procedure, this issue may have implications beyond a mere procedural formality.
The applicability and prospects of this argument depend on the individual circumstances and legal status of each investor.
Has the court addressed the notification issue?
At present, this cannot be established. The proceedings were conducted in private, and the full text of the judgment is not publicly available. MAGENTA Legal has no access to the case materials and therefore cannot confirm whether the claimant raised the notification issue or what grounds the court relied upon in dismissing the claim.
The outcome at first instance highlights the potential risks faced by investors seeking allocation after the announced deadline. However, it should not be regarded as a definitive conclusion applicable to all investors in similar circumstances. The judgment may also be appealed.
Group litigation as an alternative approach
Group litigation has been considered by other legal practitioners as a possible approach to these claims. While MAGENTA Legal does not exclude this option, we remain cautious about whether it represents the most effective procedural route.
Although investors may face a common issue concerning notification, each claim requires an individual assessment of the relevant circumstances, including:
- ownership of the shares, acquisition dates and the chain of custody;
- eligibility to participate in the allocation procedure and supporting documentation;
- entitlement to a specific number of shares; and
- the receiving account and any applicable restrictions.
In our assessment, these differences create a material risk that a court may decline to consider the claims as a group action. The additional procedural requirements may also prolong the proceedings, while an unfavourable judgment could affect several investors simultaneously.
MAGENTA Legal's current approach
MAGENTA Legal has been forming a pool of investors for the purpose of bringing several individual test claims. Following the recent court decision, we have decided to temporarily suspend the filing stage for the existing pool in order to reassess the associated legal and procedural risks and monitor further developments, including the possibility of an appeal.
The project has not been abandoned. We continue to analyse the available legal options and welcome expressions of interest from investors seeking the allocation of EVRAZ shares.
For operational updates, follow our Telegram Channel dedicated to forced conversions.
If you have individual questions or require legal support, our Telegram Bot is available for direct assistance.
You can also reach our team via the contact form on our Website.
The above reflects MAGENTA Legal's current assessment and does not constitute a guarantee of a successful outcome.